Tuesday, August 01, 2006

Propaganda wars


What has been happening on the media scene these past days defies imagination. There are two completely different groups of media outlets, and each group's news is not only different in their packaging but in the news content itself. If you try to listen to the two sides, you get two totally different images of this war, completely unrelated, as if each side is living in their own universe…


For example, two days ago, on one side there was this news items announcing that eight Israeli soldiers were killed and two more abducted. For three or four hours, this was the main headline. Then suddenly this piece of news disappeared, without any retraction. There is also the strange incident of the warplane that was supposedly shot down in Jamhour, then it turned out to be a surveillance balloon, while other speculated that it was a large missile being transported and was hit by an Israeli air raid…

Meanwhile, on the other side, the Israeli estimate of Hezbollah's death toil was 200 or so fighters. Then the numbers went down to 25 and then up, again no retraction or admitting any mistakes. Also, the news items from a week ago announcing that the Israeli army has occupied Beint Jbili, while the other side denied it saying that IDF have not even reached it, and so on…

Another example, yesterday's Israeli warship that was supposedly hit, one side was adamant, the other vehemently denied. And each day we are greeted with a supposed number of Israeli tanks destroyed, meanwhile Israel announces the death of several high ranking Hezbollah commanders every couple of days… again one side announces the news the other totally denies it.

What is even more worrisome is that each side totally believes their own source of information, never doubting or even trying to substantiate their information. On the contrary, they take for granted all their sides information and brand the other side's as total lies. Meanwhile, anyone who is still interested in some objective news and trying to understand what is really happening is left totally bewildered and clueless.

But like in everything in this wretched life, there is always a good side even to the worst situations. And it is my understanding that someone needs to win in order for this war to end, so if both parties feel that they are winning, if one hears their propaganda machines, then all the better and this will end sooner. Yet somehow, this propaganda war seems to only affecting us, the public opinion, and not both parties commands, for it seems that they know perfectly well what is happening and prefer to keep us all in the dark…

3 comments :

Akiva M said...

bob - I've proposed the outlines of a peace plan that may actually let all sides "win" on my blog - I'd love your input.

Stay safe.

Anonymous said...

I think this « media strategy » is a big part of the war! Each side has to show a part of the truth but not all the truth. As you said, it’s a real propaganda.
All my thoughts are with you…
Manal from Morocco.

Anonymous said...

very true really,
what both sides miss is that nobody wins in war, just different degrees of loss and they try as much as they can to hide who's loosing more.
Nobody is winning this for sure
Isreal had done nothing except strengthing hezoballah more than ever,they ve destroyed a whole country, weakned it's elected goverment and anyone now who talks about disarming hezboallh is looked at as a traitor.
and now hezoabllah is in tough position they have no other choice except fightening against this stupid and destructive force as everyone now looks up to them when it comes to seeking vengance 4rom the isrealis over their terrible crimes in lebnon.
im not lebanese,but lebnon has always been the 2nd dearest place to my heart, so i have some things that need to be sorted out.
why is it that on the borbers there's no lebnese army under the control of the gov instead of one part having missiles and taking decisions alone?
why isn't this territory defeneded by one lebnese army repersting all of the lebanese people instead of only one group?(no matter how just their cause is)
Ater isreal stupid aggresion is over,and it will be over soon this madness can't go on, how will the lebs deal with that?they ve shown remarable unity and an amazing attitude in getting over their differences during this hard time? but will this go on?
Nothing will tear my heart apart as seeing lebnon drageed into another civil war or becoming another Iraq.lebs know how to enjoy life way too much for that.

Love always from egypt